Your weekly perch for all things real estate.

Zillow just caught 8% of home shoppers doing something sneaky: browsing rentals at the same time. These "dual shoppers" are hedging their bets, scrolling through three-bedroom listings for sale and then, five minutes later, looking at the same thing for rent. Turns out the rent-versus-buy decision isn't a fork in the road anymore. It's a Zillow tab you keep switching between. In New York, nearly one in three home shoppers is also eyeing rentals. The data says a lot about where housing affordability really stands, and what it means for your portfolio.

NEST NUMBERS

Source: Zillow, Freddie Mac, CNBC, Redfin, Apartment List, CME FedWatch

I CHOOSE……….. BOTH

Story: Zillow's latest research reveals that about 8% of shoppers browsing for-sale listings are also actively shopping rentals. These "dual shoppers" are concentrated in the most expensive coastal markets: Los Angeles leads at 12%, followed by San Diego (10.8%) and San Francisco (10.1%). New York City is in a league of its own at 29.9%. The core tension is monthly cost. Across the homes dual shoppers actually engage with, owning runs $415/month more than renting nationally. In San Jose, that gap balloons to $3,400/month. The rentals they browse are 284 square feet smaller on average, but often deliver higher value per square foot thanks to newer finishes and better amenities. The three-bedroom home is the anchor for both searches. Dual shoppers aren't changing what they want. They're just figuring out which payment structure they can stomach.

So What? For rental investors, this is a demand signal hiding in plain sight. One in twelve home shoppers in LA, San Diego, and San Francisco is already one sticker shock away from becoming your tenant. In NYC, it's nearly one in three. These aren't casual renters. They're qualified buyers who can't close the gap, and that gap ($415/month nationally, thousands more in coastal metros) is your moat. Pay attention to where dual shopping is lowest: Hartford (4.2%), Louisville (4.3%), Buffalo (4.3%). These are markets where buying still pencils out, which means rental demand is more discretionary. If you're acquiring in markets with high dual-shopper rates, you're buying into structurally sticky tenant demand.

What’s Next? Watch mortgage rates closely. The 30-year just dipped to 6.07% (Zillow marketplace, April 15). Every basis point lower narrows the $415 gap and converts some dual shoppers into buyers. Every tick higher widens it and pushes more into the rental pool. This data also provides a framework for market selection: the metros with the highest dual shopping are also the ones with the most recession-resistant rental demand.

Source: Zillow

NESTFLIX

The 60 Second Rental Property Test (Spot Bad Deals Instantly)

In this video, Spencer Sutton breaks down how to analyze a rental property in just 60 seconds so you can quickly spot red flags and avoid bad deals. He talks about how to create a buy box, evaluate numbers, and identify deal killers like location and repairs before you invest.

NEST PICKS

Top Weekly Stories:

1️⃣ Housing: Existing home sales fell 3.6% in March to a 3.98M annual rate, with the median price hitting a record $408,800 for the 33rd consecutive month of YoY increases, even as the University of Michigan Consumer Sentiment Index plunged to 47.6, the lowest in its 74-year history. 🪺 More

2️⃣ Investors: The AEI Housing Center projects national home prices will turn negative in April for the first time since 2012, with 28 of 53 major metros (including all of Florida, California, and Texas) already posting YoY price declines, while Rust Belt cities like Kansas City (+8.6%) and Cleveland (+5.9%) are surging. 🪺 More

3️⃣ Mortgages: The 30-year fixed dropped to 6.07% on Zillow's lender marketplace (April 15), with four lenders now offering sub-6% rates, as the 30-year conforming average fell 6 basis points week-over-week to 6.28%. 🪺 More

4️⃣ Interesting Trends: Builder confidence fell four points to 34 in April (NAHB/Wells Fargo HMI), with future sales expectations dropping seven points to 42 and 60% of builders still offering incentives for the 13th consecutive month. 🪺 More

5️⃣ Policy Changes: Single-family built-for-rent starts dropped 19% in 2025 to 68,000 units (down from 84,000 in 2024), with NAHB flagging that ROAD Act institutional ownership restrictions could put another 40,000 BTR units per year at risk. 🪺 More