Rent Control Isn't Working

Your weekly perch for all things real estate.

Ever tried squeezing a balloon only to watch it bulge somewhere else? That’s rent regulation in a nutshell: New York’s laws tighten, cap rates pop, and suddenly half the country’s apartment markets spring a leak in valuations and capex.

RENT CONTROL REALITY CHECK

Story: A sweeping Trepp deep-dive tracks rent-control (and near-cousin “stabilization”) experiments from New York to Portland (both coasts!) and the Twin Cities in between. Headlines: post-2019 reforms sliced New York’s regulated multifamily values by roughly 30%, pushed CMBS delinquency on those assets to 16.4%, and left a quarter of small-landlord units vacant because rents can’t cover variable costs. San Francisco and L.A. show milder but still visible valuation discounts, while St. Paul’s 3% cap stalled new construction from ~1,000 units a year to <300. Contrast that with laissez-faire Minneapolis, where a 12% jump in housing stock kept average rents almost flat (up 1% total) over five years.

So What? Regulated markets now trade with 50–100 bps higher cap rates and scarlet-letter CMBS watch-list rates, meaning pricier debt, pickier buyers, and much more talk about “loss-to-lease.” Value-add strategies that relied on vacancy bumps or luxury repositions? File them under fiction in New York, San Fran, St. Paul, and Portland (ME). Meanwhile, supply-friendly metros are quietly handing investors the gift of stable rents plus lower legislative risk, perfect for anyone chasing predictable cash flow or 1031-exchange sanity.

What’s Next? Over the next few quarters, watch three pressure points converge: New York’s courts will rule on challenges to 2019’s HSTPA (a reversal could flood the market with long-mothballed units), Portland ME’s November ballot may soften its strict cap, and Trepp’s promised Sun Belt sequel, due later this summer, will benchmark deregulated metros like Austin and Tampa. Each data drop can reprice debt spreads and cap rates overnight, so staying nimble (and maybe setting Google alerts for “rent reform”) is the best hedge.

Source: Trepp

NEST PICKS

Top Weekly Stories:

1️⃣ SFR/Multifamily Management: Record apartment deliveries mean median asking rents slid 1% YoY, and over half of major metros booked declines. 🪺 More

2️⃣ Insurance: Wildfire-worried Arizonans just saw premiums double overnight; 12 % now gamble with no coverage. 🪺 More

3️⃣ Mortgages: The jobs report yanked 30-year rates back to 6.97 %, proof that the bond market has the emotional stability of a toddler denied snacks. 🪺 More

4️⃣ Interesting Trends: SEC says a San Fran operator ran a $46M multifamily Ponzi for 15 years. Reminder: trust, but verify the rent roll. 🪺 More

5️⃣ Policy Changes: Lawrence, IN, just launched a fast-moving “Housing Ready Task Force” to skip state-level red tape and brainstorm city-controlled fixes for renters who spend 30%+ of their income on shelter. 🪺 More

INVESTOR HIGHLIGHTS:

👉 Off-Market Deal: Missouri Off-Market Deal